semantic: 0.155
other: 0.139
debug: 0.124
network: 0.095
device: 0.083
socket: 0.081
graphic: 0.078
performance: 0.064
PID: 0.042
vnc: 0.038
permissions: 0.031
boot: 0.029
files: 0.024
KVM: 0.017
network: 0.689
debug: 0.242
other: 0.013
socket: 0.011
PID: 0.010
files: 0.010
semantic: 0.005
device: 0.005
performance: 0.003
graphic: 0.003
boot: 0.003
permissions: 0.003
vnc: 0.002
KVM: 0.001

Slirp Broadcast traffic

Hi all,

Version: QEMU emulator version 3.1.0 (Debian 1:3.1+dfsg-7+build1)

I'm running some DHCP traffic to a *custom* DHCP server with user-mode networking in QEMU. I'm using port 30067 for the server, so this does not conflict with the built-in DHCP server.

DHCP broadcasts to and from the server, and I'm observing issues with both sending and receiving packets.

Firstly, from the VM, a packet sent to IPv4 x.x.x.2:30067 (gateway) makes it to the server, but a packet sent to 255.255.255.255 does not. I'd suspect that Slirp has to support sending to the broadcast IP address? Or is this something I can turn on with a configuration option? (My QEMU version too old?)

Secondly, the source address in a DHCP IPv4 packet must be 0.0.0.0 (by RFC). That means that any return packet will have 0.0.0.0 swapped in as its destination address. However, that packet doesn't make it into the VM at all. I know that if you deliver this packet to Linux, a raw socket will spit it back out. The packets' destination address should not prevent the packet from being delivered to the right VM, since Slirp (should?) know exactly which VM the session belongs to. (It's a proxy, not a router.)

WDYT? Did I miss some configuration options or use too old a version?

Thanks,
Chris

slirp has been moved to a standalone project, can you report here:
https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/slirp/libslirp/issues

I don't have an answer off the top of my head, but I would suggest looking/tweaking at the network mask. And for the receive side, debugging from sorecvfrom().

Thanks. Opened https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/slirp/libslirp/issues/9.

The ticket in the libslirp tracker has been closed a year ago, so I think we can close this ticket here, too.