1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
|
<think>
Okay, I need to figure out whether this bug in QEMU is related to user-mode or system-mode. Let me start by understanding the problem.
The issue is that when using `qemu-x86_64` to run an amd64 build of curl against a URL, it results in an SSL error: "curl: (35) error:1416D07B:SSL routines:tls_process_key_exchange:bad signature." This happens specifically after commit 16fc5726a6. The same command works with `qemu-aarch64` and the previous QEMU commit.
First, I'll recall what user-mode emulation involves. User-mode emulators translate guest CPU instructions to host CPU instructions on a per-instruction basis without needing the full OS stack. They often handle system calls by intercepting them and translating them into equivalent host calls. Examples include tools like qemu-user (e.g., qemu-x86_64) which is used here.
System-mode, on the other hand, involves running a full virtual machine with its own kernel and device emulation. It's more resource-intensive but allows for running entire OS images as VMs.
In this case, the user is using `qemu-x86_64` to run an amd64 binary, which suggests they're in user-mode since it's not a full VM setup but rather executing a foreign binary directly. The problem occurs during SSL/TLS handshake, specifically with key exchange signature processing.
So why would this happen? Let me think about the components involved. The curl command is making an HTTPS request, so it uses OpenSSL or similar libraries for SSL/TLS. When running under QEMU user-mode, certain system calls and library interactions are emulated or translated.
The error points to a bad signature during key exchange processing in the SSL routines. This could be due to incorrect handling of cryptographic operations, perhaps because the emulation is not correctly providing the necessary environment for OpenSSL's operations.
Looking at commit 16fc5726a6, I don't have its exact details, but since it caused this issue, it likely introduced changes in how user-mode handles certain instructions or system calls related to crypto. Maybe there was a change in how CPU features are handled, especially those related to AES or other cryptographic extensions.
In user-mode, if QEMU doesn't correctly expose the necessary CPU flags (like aes, avx) to the guest binary, applications relying on these might behave incorrectly. OpenSSL uses various optimized routines based on CPU capabilities. If the host and guest have different capabilities, but QEMU isn't properly translating or setting the right flags, it could lead to mismatches.
For example, if the curl binary was compiled with AES-NI instructions and expects them to be available, but under user-mode, these aren't correctly emulated or passed through, then OpenSSL might fall back to slower, non-AES methods. However, in this case, the error is about a bad signature during key exchange, which suggests a failure in processing an ECDSA or RSA signature.
Another possibility is that the SSL/TLS handshake involves timing-sensitive operations, and QEMU's user-mode emulator introduces delays or inaccuracies that cause the handshake to fail. But that seems less likely as it would probably affect more operations, not just SSL.
Alternatively, perhaps there's a regression in how system calls related to entropy or random number generation are handled under user-mode after the commit. If the guest application isn't getting sufficient entropy, it might produce weak keys leading to signature issues. However, curl is using the system's OpenSSL which should handle that unless there's an issue with how QEMU provides entropy.
Also, since the aarch64 version works fine, maybe the problem lies in how x86_64 instructions are being translated or how certain x86-specific features are handled under user-mode. It could be that after commit 16fc5726a6, some instruction translations for x86_64 were altered, affecting how OpenSSL's assembly optimizations work within the guest binary.
To sum up, since this issue arises in the context of running an amd64 binary via QEMU user-mode (qemu-x86_64), and not in system-mode or aarch64 setup, it points towards a problem within the user-mode emulation. The bug is likely related to how certain instructions or system calls are handled when emulating x86_64 binaries under user-mode after that specific commit.
</think>
user
|