1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
|
<think>
Okay, so I'm trying to figure out whether this bug is related to user-mode or system-mode in QEMU. Let me go through the problem step by step.
First, the issue arises when running a test case linked earlier, and it results in `apt update` failing with GPG errors. The error messages indicate that the signatures are invalid, which usually means there's an issue with key verification.
The user mentioned that setting `sysctl vm.mmap_min_addr=53248` fixes the problem. By default, this value is higher (65536). This makes me think it's related to memory mappings in the system. The `vm.mmap_min_addr` parameter controls the lowest address that a process can map when using `mmap()`. Lowering it allows more memory regions to be accessible by user processes.
The bisecting information shows that the bug appears after a certain commit, which suggests a regression introduced in newer versions of QEMU. The problem started manifesting differently between two commits: one where `apt update` works but package lists are empty, and another where it fails with invalid signatures.
Looking at how apt interacts, it uses `/usr/lib/apt/methods/gpgv`, which communicates through stdin. This process then launches `/usr/bin/apt-key`. The error message is about allocating a guest commpage: "Operation not permitted."
The key here is understanding that this allocation happens when running in QEMU's environment. Since the problem only occurs when `gpgv` is run through apt and not directly, it's likely due to how QEMU handles certain operations in user-mode versus system-mode.
In user-mode emulation, QEMU runs processes as if they're on a different architecture without full OS virtualization. This might involve more restrictive memory mappings or privileges compared to system-mode. The fact that lowering `vm.mmap_min_addr` helps suggests it's about the process's ability to access lower memory addresses, which could be restricted in user-mode.
System-mode QEMU typically provides a higher level of isolation and might handle memory differently, especially for kernel-level operations. However, since the issue is occurring with user-space applications like apt and gpgv, it points more towards user-mode where such restrictions are applied to prevent certain attacks or overflows.
Additionally, the error message about allocating the commpage being denied indicates that the process doesn't have the necessary permissions. In user-mode, QEMU imposes stricter controls on memory mappings compared to system-mode, which might explain why lowering `mmap_min_addr` allows it to work.
Putting this together, the bug seems related to how QEMU's user-mode handles memory allocations for processes, specifically affecting apt's ability to verify signatures because of these restrictions. Therefore, this is likely a user-mode issue.
</think>
user
|