1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
|
<think>
Okay, let's try to figure out what category this bug falls into. The user says that when they run a program under QEMU's user mode for MIPS and MIPS64, it hangs instead of crashing when a weak symbol is accessed. The issue is related to QEMU, so I need to see which category fits: instruction, syscall, or runtime.
Looking at the problem: The program is supposed to crash because a weak symbol is NULL, but QEMU hangs. The stack trace from GDB shows that QEMU is stuck in gen_intermediate_code, which is part of the translation process for the target architecture. The function gen_intermediate_code is in translate.c for MIPS, which suggests it's about translating the guest's machine instructions into host instructions.
The backtrace shows that the program is stuck in a mutex lock when generating intermediate code. The function tb_lock is part of the code generation process. This seems to be a problem during the execution of the guest code, specifically during the dynamic translation of instructions.
Since the issue is happening during the translation or execution of the guest's instructions, it's likely related to how QEMU handles the specific instructions for MIPS when dealing with weak symbols. Weak symbols might involve certain instruction patterns that QEMU isn't handling correctly, leading to an infinite loop or deadlock in the translation process.
Syscall errors usually involve system calls made by the emulated program, but here the problem occurs before that, during code execution. Runtime errors are a bit broad, but since this is about instruction translation, maybe it's more specific to instructions. However, the options are instruction, syscall, or runtime.
Wait, the problem is that QEMU is hanging when processing the code that accesses the weak symbol. Since weak symbols might result in certain memory accesses or instructions that QEMU's translator isn't handling correctly, this could be an instruction-level issue. The gen_intermediate_code function is responsible for translating guest instructions, so a faulty translation could lead to an infinite loop.
But maybe it's a runtime issue because it's during execution. However, the classification options don't have a 'translation' category. The options are instruction, syscall, or runtime. Since the problem is during the translation phase (gen_intermediate_code), which is part of handling the instructions, maybe it's an instruction-related bug. However, the user says that the program is supposed to crash but QEMU hangs. The root cause is QEMU's handling of the code execution, which might be a runtime issue.
Alternatively, since the hang occurs during the generation of intermediate code for the target instructions, it's an issue with how QEMU processes the specific instructions for MIPS when a weak symbol is involved. Therefore, this would be an 'instruction' category bug because it's related to the correct handling of the guest instructions by QEMU's translator.
But wait, the problem is that when the weak symbol (which is NULL) is accessed, the program should crash, but QEMU isn't handling the resulting fault properly. However, the backtrace shows that QEMU itself is hanging in its own code when trying to generate code. That suggests that the QEMU emulator is stuck in an infinite loop during translation, perhaps due to some invalid instruction pattern caused by the NULL pointer access. But why would accessing a NULL pointer cause QEMU to hang during translation? Maybe the program counter is at an invalid address, leading QEMU to try to translate code at an invalid location.
In that case, the problem is that QEMU's code generation for MIPS isn't handling an invalid PC value correctly, leading to an infinite loop in gen_intermediate_code. That would be an instruction-related issue because it's about translating the wrong instructions. Therefore, the category is 'instruction'.
</think>
instruction
|